Where to Stay in Cape May, NJ

Beach Avenue runs the full length of the waterfront, giving every hotel on the block direct beach access. Congress Hall at 251 Beach Ave anchors the strip. Ocean Street, Hughes Street, and Stockton Place branch inland through a dense grid of ornate Victorian B&Bs. Columbia Avenue, two blocks from the water, has some of the most photographed 19th-century cottages in the country. The Promenade boardwalk fronts the whole strip. Washington Street Mall is a 5-minute walk west. Parking is brutal in July and August, so arrive by Friday afternoon or take the Cape May-Lewes Ferry foot passenger option instead.

Best for

First-timerscouplesanyone who wants zero friction between waking up and hitting the sand

Walk times

Cape May Beach 1 min
Washington Street Mall 5 min
The Lobster House at Fisherman's Wharf 15 min

Skip if: You are traveling with a car and hate paying $25/day for parking, or you want peace and quiet after 10pm

Local tip: Congress Hall's Brown Room bar opens to non-guests. Order a drink and use their beach chairs on a weekday afternoon when it is half-empty.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$280per night

Washington Street Mall Area

Walkable shopping hub, 3 blocks from the water

Mid-range $150-$350/night

Washington Street itself is a pedestrian-only mall running from Ocean Street to Decatur Street, lined with boutiques, fudge shops, and restaurants. Perry Street, Jackson Street, and Franklin Street form the surrounding grid with mid-range inns and motels. Pittsburgh Avenue and Madison Avenue have motel-style properties at 20 to 30 percent below beachfront rates. Louie's Pizza on Perry Street is a locals staple. The beach is a 7-minute walk east. Fisherman's Wharf, home to The Lobster House and working commercial boats, is a 10-minute walk south on Lafayette Street. Parking is slightly easier here than on the beach strip.

Best for

Repeat visitors who know the beach is always therecouples who prioritize dining and shopping over ocean views

Walk times

Cape May Beach 7 min
Washington Street Mall center 2 min
Fisherman's Wharf 10 min

Skip if: You want to wake up and see the water from your window

Local tip: Grab coffee at Pier 622 on Lafayette Street before the Beach Avenue crowds arrive. Lines there stay short until 9am.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$168per night

West Cape May

Residential borough, real savings, local feel

Mid-range $120-$280/night

West Cape May is a separate borough just west of Cape May proper. Cross over via Sunset Boulevard or Broadway and the density drops immediately. Stevens Street and Elmira Street have vacation rental houses popular with families booking by the week. Willow Creek Winery sits at 152 Sunset Blvd with tastings and a farm market. The Cape May Bird Observatory on East Lake Drive draws serious birders during spring and fall migration. Broadway has grocery stores, a laundromat, and local diners with no tourist markup. The main beach is a 15-minute walk or a short bike ride east. Rates run 30 to 40 percent below beachfront pricing.

Best for

Families renting by the weekbirderstravelers who want a kitchen and a yard without paying peak Cape May rates

Walk times

Cape May Beach 18 min
Willow Creek Winery 6 min
Washington Street Mall 20 min

Skip if: You want to walk to the beach without planning it, or you are here for only a night or two

Local tip: Willow Creek Winery does free entry on weekday afternoons. Their rose sells out by Saturday. Go Thursday.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$134per night

Cape May Point

Silent tip of the cape, lighthouse, shell beach

Mid-range $130-$300/night

Cape May Point is its own borough at the very southern end of the peninsula. Lighthouse Avenue leads directly to the 1859 Cape May Lighthouse, 157 feet tall with views to the Delaware coast. Lake Drive circles Cape May Point State Park, where a WWII concrete observation bunker sits at the shore and birding trails cut through coastal scrub. Pavilion Avenue and Alexander Avenue have small Victorian cottages available as weekly rentals. There is no commercial strip, no bars, no noise after 9pm. The shell beach at the very tip is the best spot in New Jersey to find Cape May Diamonds, the quartz pebbles locals collect.

Best for

Couples wanting seclusionbirders during peak migrationanyone who finds the main town too crowded

Walk times

Cape May Lighthouse 4 min
Shell Beach at Delaware Bay tip 10 min
Cape May Beach (bike or drive) 12 min

Skip if: You want restaurants, nightlife, or easy beach access. There are no restaurants in Cape May Point.

Local tip: Sunset over Delaware Bay from the state park is better than any beach view in the main town. Walk down Lake Drive at 7:30pm in summer.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$146per night