Where to Stay in Nantucket

Nantucket Town clusters around the cobblestoned intersection of Main Street and Federal Street, putting you within walking distance of everything that matters. The Steamship Authority docks at Steamship Wharf, a 6-minute walk from most upper-town lodging. Old South Wharf sits 8 minutes from the top of Main, with waterfront restaurants and the Hy-Line fast ferry terminal 3 minutes beyond that. The Nantucket Whaling Museum anchors Broad Street, a 5-minute stroll east. Centre Street carries the boutiques and galleries. The honest downside: summer evenings are loud, parking is effectively nonexistent, and street noise bleeds through older inn walls. Request a courtyard-facing room in writing before you arrive. July and August are shoulder-to-shoulder with day-trippers by noon. But the upside is real. You genuinely need nothing except your own two feet. A 12-minute radius covers the entire downtown core.

Best for

first-time visitorscouplescar-free travelers

Walk times

Steamship Authority ferry terminal 6 min
Main Street restaurants 3 min
Children's Beach 10 min

Skip if: You need quiet sleep, have a tight budget, or are visiting in peak July and August.

Local tip: Upper Main Street lodging gets significantly less foot-traffic noise than properties near the harbor end. Ask which side of the building your room faces before you confirm the booking.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$392per night

Brant Point

Lighthouse views, harbor calm, close enough to Town to matter.

Luxury $280-$550/night

Brant Point curls around the harbor entrance just north of downtown on the slender neck of land where Easton Street and North Beach Street carry most of the residential accommodation. The Brant Point Lighthouse, built in 1746 and the second oldest in the United States, marks the channel 4 minutes from most lodging here. Nantucket Town center is a 15-minute walk along the harbor waterfront. Children's Beach sits 7 minutes south, making this the strongest family option within easy range of Town. The neighborhood retains a genuinely residential feel even in peak summer, far quieter than the inn-dense blocks around Main Street. Restaurants require a walk or bike ride to Town, which is the main trade-off. Harbor light at dawn is extraordinary here, with fishing boats heading out before the ferries start running. Bikes sharpen the area considerably.

Best for

familiescouples wanting harbor viewsrepeat visitors who know Town well

Walk times

Nantucket Town center 15 min
Brant Point Lighthouse 4 min
Children's Beach 7 min

Skip if: You want to roll out of bed and straight onto restaurant row without planning.

Local tip: Walk the harbor path at sunrise before the ferries start. The lighthouse against incoming boats at low light is the best free view on the island and you will have it entirely to yourself.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$314per night

Siasconset (Sconset)

Rose-covered cottages, zero nightlife. Exactly the point.

Luxury $450-$950/night

Siasconset, called Sconset by everyone on the island, sits 7 miles east of Town on the Atlantic-facing bluff. Getting there requires a 30-minute bike ride along the Milestone Road bike path, a taxi, or the NRTA Wave bus from Town. The reward is one of the most genuinely beautiful village atmospheres in New England. Broadway in Sconset is a lane barely wide enough for one car, lined with rose-covered shingled cottages dating to the late 1600s when Nantucket fishermen built seasonal shanties here for the summer haul. The Sankaty Head Lighthouse sits at the north end of the village, a 15-minute walk along the bluff path. The Sconset Cafe serves breakfast with zero pretense. There is no commercial noise, no nightlife, and no crowds even in August. Prices reflect it fully.

Best for

solitude seekershistory loversluxury travelers on repeat visits

Walk times

Sconset village center 5 min
Sankaty Head Lighthouse 15 min
Sconset Beach 8 min

Skip if: This is your first Nantucket trip, you need nightlife, or you are traveling without a car or bike plan.

Local tip: The Milestone Road bike path from Town to Sconset is flat, paved, and scenic. Ride it once and you will understand why some guests never leave the village for their entire stay.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$504per night

Surfside

Open Atlantic at your door. Town is three miles north and worth the ride.

Luxury $180-$380/night

Surfside anchors the south shore about 3 miles from Town via the flat, paved Surfside Road bike path, a 20-minute ride on a standard rental. The beach here is open Atlantic, long, and genuinely good for swimming and bodyboarding unlike the calmer harbor beaches near Town. Accommodation clusters along Surfside Road and surrounding streets, mostly cottages and small inns rather than grand Victorian properties. The trade-off is concrete: you need a bike or the NRTA Wave bus to reach any restaurant, the ferry, or a grocery store. The bus runs on a regular schedule in season at $2 per ride. Surfside holds Nantucket's most accessible price points outside of renting a full house. For families with children who prioritize beach access over walkability, Surfside delivers more value than Town at significantly lower nightly rates.

Best for

budget-conscious travelersswimmers and bodyboardersfamilies with beach-first itineraries

Walk times

Surfside Beach 5 min
NRTA Wave bus stop 3 min
Nantucket Town (by bike) 20 min

Skip if: You want to walk to dinner without planning or do not intend to rent a bike.

Local tip: The Surfside Beach parking lot fills completely by 10am on summer weekends. If you are biking from Town, leave by 9am to claim a spot on the sand before the day-tripper buses arrive.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$202per night

Madaket

The island's best sunsets and almost nothing else. Perfect if that is what you came for.

Luxury $200-$450/night

Madaket sits at the far western tip of the island, 6 miles from Town at the end of the Madaket Road bike path. The ride takes about 35 minutes on a flat, paved surface paralleling the road. This is the least developed corner of Nantucket: a handful of residential streets, Madaket Beach stretching in both directions, and virtually zero commercial activity. Millie's is the one notable exception, a seasonal restaurant on the approach road worth the trip for fish tacos and harbor views. Sunsets here are the best on the island, full western exposure over open water with nothing blocking the horizon. The NRTA Wave bus connects Madaket to Town throughout the season. Staying here means committing to the quiet life. There are no pharmacies, coffee shops, or grocery stores within walking distance. That is the entire appeal for the visitors who choose it year after year.

Best for

sunset chaserscouples wanting genuine isolationrepeat visitors who know the island deeply

Walk times

Madaket Beach 5 min
Millie's restaurant 10 min
Nantucket Town (by bike) 35 min

Skip if: This is your first visit and you want to see more than one part of the island in a week.

Local tip: Bring everything you need for the day before leaving Town. The nearest pharmacy is back in Town. Forgetting sunscreen means a 35-minute round-trip ride that will eat your afternoon.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

$224per night