Where to Stay Guide

Where to Stay When Visiting New York City

4 neighborhoods, honest trade-offs, no fluff. Here is where first-timers and repeat visitors actually book.

S
Sarah Mitchell North America Travel Guide

01

Midtown Manhattan

Maximum convenience, minimum local feel

Budget $0-$0/night

Midtown puts you within walking distance of Times Square, the Empire State Building, and Grand Central Terminal on 42nd Street. The stretch between 5th and 8th Avenues is dense with hotels at every price point. You can walk to the High Line via 34th Street, reach Central Park South in 15 minutes, and hop any subway line at nearly every corner. It is loud, crowded, and relentlessly touristy. But nothing beats stepping out at 7am and already being in the middle of everything. Stay near Lexington Avenue for blocks that are noticeably quieter without sacrificing any transit access.

Best for
First-time visitors who want landmark access without figuring out transit on day one
Walk times
  • Times Square 5 min
  • Central Park South 15 min
  • Grand Central Terminal 8 min
Skip if: You hate tourist crowds and paying $28 for a mediocre hotel breakfast
Local tip: Stay east of 6th Avenue. The blocks around Lexington and 3rd Avenue have the same subway access but 40 percent less foot traffic and hotels that run 15 to 20 percent cheaper.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

RecommendedHotels.com
Hotels.com
Best price tonight
per night
Check availability →
Expedia
Expedia
Free cancellation available
per night
Check availability →
02

East Village

Real New York, cheap eats, zero tourist buses

Budget $0-$0/night

The East Village sits between 14th Street and Houston Street, anchored by St. Marks Place and Tompkins Square Park. This is where New Yorkers actually go out on a Tuesday. Ramen on 1st Avenue, dive bars on Avenue A, vinyl shops on 9th Street. Hotels here are fewer and smaller, but rates reflect it. The L train at 14th Street and the 4/5/6 at Union Square push you to Midtown in 20 minutes and Brooklyn in 15. Weekend noise after midnight on the main avenues is real. Request a room above the fourth floor when booking.

Best for
Solo travelersrepeat visitorsand anyone who wants late-night food options within two blocks
Walk times
  • Union Square (4/5/6/L/N/Q/R trains) 10 min
  • Brooklyn Bridge 28 min
  • High Line 32 min
Skip if: You have 8am Midtown meetings every day or you are traveling with children under 10
Local tip: Veselka on 2nd Avenue is open 24 hours and serves the best borscht in the city for under $12. Skip the brunch lines at the trendy spots on 7th Street.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

RecommendedHotels.com
Hotels.com
Best price tonight
per night
Check availability →
Expedia
Expedia
Free cancellation available
per night
Check availability →
03

Williamsburg, Brooklyn

Where locals moved when Manhattan got too expensive

Budget $0-$0/night

Williamsburg runs along Bedford Avenue from Metropolitan Avenue down to East River State Park at the waterfront. The L train from Bedford Avenue station drops you at 14th Street in Manhattan in 8 minutes flat. You get rooftop bars with unobstructed skyline views, serious restaurants on Graham Avenue, and Smorgasburg food market on weekend mornings in summer. Hotel rooms are larger and 30 to 40 percent cheaper than equivalent Midtown properties. The L train does suspend for weekend maintenance occasionally. Check the MTA schedule on mta.info before finalizing your dates.

Best for
Design-conscious travelersanyone visiting for food or musicand budget-focused visitors who still want style
Walk times
  • Bedford Avenue L Train station 5 min
  • East River State Park 10 min
  • Smorgasburg (weekends April to October) 15 min
Skip if: You are doing the full tourist loop every day. Statue of Liberty, Empire State, MoMA. The transit adds 25 minutes each way.
Local tip: The Wythe Hotel rooftop bar is worth one visit even if you are not a guest. The Manhattan skyline at golden hour from there is the best free view in New York.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

RecommendedHotels.com
Hotels.com
Best price tonight
per night
Check availability →
Expedia
Expedia
Free cancellation available
per night
Check availability →
04

Upper West Side

Calm, residential, and closer to everything than it looks

Budget $0-$0/night

The Upper West Side runs from 59th Street to 110th Street between Central Park West and Riverside Drive. Amsterdam Avenue and Columbus Avenue are lined with neighborhood restaurants, zero tourist traps, and bakeries that have been open since 1985. Central Park is directly across the street from most hotels here. The American Museum of Natural History sits at 79th Street and Central Park West. The 1/2/3 subway on Broadway carries you to Midtown in 10 minutes and the Financial District in 30. Streets go quiet by 10pm. It is the most livable stretch of Manhattan for a week-long stay.

Best for
Familiesvisitors staying more than 5 nightsand anyone who wants Central Park access without Midtown prices
Walk times
  • Central Park (72nd Street entrance) 4 min
  • American Museum of Natural History 8 min
  • Times Square (by 1/2/3 subway) 12 min
Skip if: You want to walk to nightlife or downtown attractions without taking the subway
Local tip: Zabar's on Broadway at 80th Street is a New York institution open since 1934. Get a bagel with lox before your morning Central Park walk and you will understand why people love this neighborhood.

Compare prices across providers

Prices shown for 1 room, 2 adults. Click to see current availability.

RecommendedHotels.com
Hotels.com
Best price tonight
per night
Check availability →
Expedia
Expedia
Free cancellation available
per night
Check availability →
Browse all hotels →

Area Price/Night Price From UsdTransitTourist DensityLocal FeelBest For First Time
Midtown Manhattan 180 Excellent Very High Low Yes
East Village 120 Good Low High No
Williamsburg, Brooklyn 110 Good Low Very High No
Upper West Side 150 Excellent Low Medium Yes
Browse all hotels →

Which NYC neighborhood is best for first-time visitors?

Midtown is the practical answer if you want zero friction. Times Square is 5 minutes on foot, the subway connects everywhere, and hotels cluster at every budget from $180 per night upward. But if you can handle 10 extra minutes of transit, the Upper West Side gives you Central Park access, quieter streets, and the same 1/2/3 subway lines starting around $150 per night for comparable quality.

Is it worth staying in Brooklyn instead of Manhattan for a first trip to NYC?

Yes, but only in Williamsburg. The L train at Bedford Avenue drops you at 14th Street in Manhattan in 8 minutes, rooms run 30 to 40 percent cheaper than Midtown equivalents, and the restaurants on Bedford and Graham Avenues beat anything in Times Square. Avoid outer Brooklyn neighborhoods like Bushwick or Bed-Stuy on a first trip. The savings look attractive but the commute to Midtown runs 45 minutes each way.

How much should I budget per night for a hotel in New York City?

Budget hotels in Midtown start around $180 per night for a private room and bathroom. Mid-range options with decent space and good locations run $250 to $350. Anything under $130 in Manhattan typically means a shared bathroom or a very small room. East Village and Williamsburg drop those numbers by 25 to 35 percent without cutting corners on quality. Prices spike by 20 to 40 percent in September, October, and around major holidays.

Which part of NYC should I avoid when booking a hotel?

Skip the blocks directly around Penn Station and Port Authority between 34th and 42nd Streets west of 7th Avenue. Hotels there charge Midtown prices for streets that are loud, gritty, and surrounded by bus exhaust. Times Square itself works for access but stays noisy past 2am. The blocks around Herald Square on 34th Street near Macy's offer better value at the same price and are only 5 minutes walk from the worst of it.




via

Found your area? Book When Visiting New York City now.

We compared 4 areas in When Visiting New York City. Now check real prices and availability.

Browse When Visiting New York City hotels

S
Written by

Sarah Mitchell

North America Travel Guide at HotelsVetted

Sarah has driven every stretch of Route 66, slept in canyon-side lodges in Utah, and tracked down the best value hotels in cities from Miami to Vancouver. She covers the USA and Canada with an emphasis on helping people understand which neighborhood to pick before they book.