The best hotels in Oaxaca
With 8,000+ places to stay across the city, the coast, and the valleys, picking the right hotel in Oaxaca is genuinely hard. We reviewed the standouts. these 10 made the cut.
Our Top Picks in Oaxaca
Click any hotel to check availability and book at the best price.
Hotel Las Mariposas
Centro Histórico, Oaxaca City
Free cancellation & Pay later
Hotel Azul Cielo
Zicatela, Puerto Escondido
Free cancellation & Pay later
Parador San Agustín
Centro Histórico, Oaxaca City
Free cancellation & Pay later
Hotel Santa Rosa
La Crucecita, Huatulco
Free cancellation & Pay later
Hotel Boutique Casa Oaxaca
Santo Tomás Xochimilco, Oaxaca City
Free cancellation & Pay later
Villas Carrizalillo
Playa Carrizalillo, Puerto Escondido
Free cancellation & Pay later
Quinta Real Oaxaca
Centro Histórico, Oaxaca City
Free cancellation & Pay later
Imala Hotel Boutique
Valle de Oaxaca, Tlacolula
Free cancellation & Pay later
Encanto Resort and Spa
Bahía de Chahué, Huatulco
Free cancellation & Pay later
All Hotels Compared
Side-by-side comparison to help you pick the right hotel. Prices reflect shoulder season averages.
| # | Hotel | City & Area | Price/Night | Score | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Casa Arnel | Jalatlaco, Oaxaca City | $45–75/night | 8.1/10 | Budget Pick |
| 2 | Hotel Las Mariposas | Centro Histórico, Oaxaca City | $65–95/night | 8.3/10 | Best Value |
| 3 | Hotel Azul Cielo | Zicatela, Puerto Escondido | $105–160/night | 8.4/10 | Best Location |
| 4 | Parador San Agustín | Centro Histórico, Oaxaca City | $120–175/night | 8.6/10 | Most Popular |
| 5 | Hotel Santa Rosa | La Crucecita, Huatulco | $130–185/night | 8.2/10 | Family Friendly |
| 6 | Hotel Boutique Casa Oaxaca | Santo Tomás Xochimilco, Oaxaca City | $155–210/night | 9/10 | Romantic Stay |
| 7 | Villas Carrizalillo | Playa Carrizalillo, Puerto Escondido | $165–220/night | 8.7/10 | Hidden Gem |
| 8 | Quinta Real Oaxaca | Centro Histórico, Oaxaca City | $195–240/night | 9.1/10 | Top Rated |
| 9 | Imala Hotel Boutique | Valle de Oaxaca, Tlacolula | $260–340/night | 9.2/10 | Luxury Pick |
| 10 | Encanto Resort and Spa | Bahía de Chahué, Huatulco | $320–480/night | 9/10 | Romantic Stay |
Why These Hotels Made Our List
Every hotel earned its spot. Here's exactly why we picked each one.
Casa Arnel
Casa Arnel sits on a quiet street in Jalatlaco, one of the most charming neighborhoods in Oaxaca City. Rooms are basic but clean, with good natural light and comfortable beds. The family-run atmosphere makes it feel genuinely welcoming rather than transactional. Breakfast is included and fills you up properly before a day of walking. A solid base if you want to save money without sleeping somewhere grim.
Check Availability
Hotel Las Mariposas
Las Mariposas is a small guesthouse a few blocks from the Zócalo, run by the same family for decades. The courtyard fills with plants and the occasional cat, which sets the tone for the whole place. Rooms vary in size, so ask for one on the upper floor for more light. The owners give genuinely useful local tips, not the tourist-brochure kind. It punches well above its price range.
Check Availability
Hotel Azul Cielo
Azul Cielo sits directly on Zicatela Beach, one of the most famous surf breaks in Mexico. Rooms have ocean-facing balconies and the sound of waves is constant. The pool is small but well-positioned for watching surfers in the afternoon. Food at the on-site restaurant is decent, heavy on fresh fish. Bring earplugs if you are a light sleeper, the beach scene gets loud at night.
Check Availability
Parador San Agustín
The Parador San Agustín occupies a colonial building on Calle Armenta y López, close to the Mercado 20 de Noviembre. The interior courtyard is beautiful and a good spot for morning coffee. Rooms are well-furnished with local textiles and the beds are genuinely comfortable. Service is attentive without being intrusive. It books up fast during Guelaguetza, so plan ahead.
Check Availability
Hotel Santa Rosa
Hotel Santa Rosa is in La Crucecita, the main town hub of Huatulco, walking distance from restaurants, markets, and bus connections. The pool area is spacious and the rooms are large enough for families traveling with kids. Air conditioning works reliably, which matters a lot in the coastal heat. Staff are helpful with arranging bay tours and snorkeling trips. It is not a resort experience, but it is comfortable and well-priced for the location.
Check Availability
Hotel Boutique Casa Oaxaca
Casa Oaxaca is a small boutique hotel with only nine rooms, set in a beautifully restored colonial house in a quieter residential neighborhood. The restaurant on site is one of the best in the city, run by chef Alejandro Ruiz, and worth a visit even if you are not staying here. Rooms are stylish without trying too hard, with local art and handwoven textiles throughout. The rooftop terrace has clear views of the mountains. This place earns its reputation.
Check Availability
Villas Carrizalillo
Villas Carrizalillo sits on the cliffs above Playa Carrizalillo, a protected cove that is calmer and cleaner than Zicatela. The walk down to the beach takes about five minutes on a stone staircase. Rooms are spacious with private terraces and good air conditioning. The pool area has a strong view of the bay below. It feels secluded compared to other Puerto Escondido options, which is exactly the point.
Check Availability
Quinta Real Oaxaca
Quinta Real Oaxaca is built inside a 16th-century convent on Calle 5 de Mayo, one of the most historically significant buildings in the city. The architecture alone justifies the stay, with original stone arches and a dramatic central courtyard. Rooms are large and carefully designed, mixing period details with modern comfort. The service standard is high and the staff handle requests without fuss. It is the most complete hotel experience in the city center.
Check Availability
Imala Hotel Boutique
Imala is a design-forward boutique hotel in Tlacolula, about 30 kilometers east of Oaxaca City in the heart of the Central Valleys. The property is surrounded by agave fields and the views of the surrounding landscape are unobstructed in every direction. Each of the eight rooms has a private terrace and the interiors use local stone, wood, and weaving in a way that feels thoughtful rather than decorative. Mezcal tasting experiences are arranged directly with nearby distilleries. It is a genuinely distinct stay for travelers who want to be outside the city.
Check Availability
Encanto Resort and Spa
Encanto sits on a private stretch of Bahía de Chahué, one of the quieter bays in the Huatulco national park area. The property has a full spa, multiple pools, and a restaurant that focuses on Oaxacan coastal ingredients. Rooms are large with ocean views and high-quality linens throughout. The beach in front of the hotel is clean and calm, suitable for swimming most of the year. It is a proper luxury resort without the overcrowded, all-inclusive energy found elsewhere on the coast.
Check AvailabilityWhere to Stay in Oaxaca
The neighborhood you pick matters more than the hotel.
First time in Oaxaca City? Start here.
Book a room in Centro Histórico or Jalatlaco. Full stop. These two neighborhoods put you within walking distance of every major sight: the Zócalo, Templo de Santo Domingo, Mercado 20 de Noviembre, and the mezcal bars on Calle Murguía. Everything else in the city is a taxi ride away.
Your first morning, walk north on Calle Macedonio Alcalá from the Zócalo. This pedestrian street is the spine of the historic center and takes you straight to Santo Domingo in about 8 minutes. Don't take a tour bus for this. You'll miss everything interesting by going too fast.
Oaxaca City vs. the coast: which one is right for you?
Oaxaca City is one of Mexico's best cultural destinations. Great food, great mezcal, world-class markets, and pre-Columbian ruins 9 km from the Zócalo at Monte Albán. It's a city you could spend a week in and still miss things.
Puerto Escondido and Huatulco are genuinely different trips. The coast means beaches, seafood, and slower days. Most people do both on one visit: 4-5 days in the city, then fly 25 minutes to the coast. The budget difference is real: you can find a solid room in Jalatlaco for $45-75/night, while Huatulco's better hotels start around $130/night.
How to survive Día de Muertos in Oaxaca without getting burned on hotels.
November 1-2 is one of the most extraordinary things you can witness in Mexico. The Panteón General cemetery on Calle de los Muertos fills with families, marigolds, and candlelight from around 10 PM. It's not a tourist show. It's a real community event that happens to be open to respectful visitors.
Book your hotel by late August at the latest. Seriously. Centro Histórico and Jalatlaco fill up completely, and prices jump 40-70% above normal rates. If you arrive without a booking, you're looking at last-minute rooms in neighborhoods far from the action, or paying $300+ for something that usually costs $100. We've seen this mistake hundreds of times.
The Valle de Oaxaca: day trip or overnight stay?
Most visitors do the valley as a day trip from the city: Tlacolula market on Sunday, a stop at a palenque mezcal distillery near Matatlán, and maybe Hierve el Agua's mineral springs before heading back. That works fine. But if you stay overnight at somewhere like Imala in Tlacolula, you get the market before the tour groups arrive, which is a completely different experience.
The valley sits at about 1,500 m elevation, same as Oaxaca City, so temperatures are similar: cool mornings, warm afternoons. Rent a car from the city for about $35-50/day or take the colectivo from the second-class terminal for 25-35 pesos. Don't bother with private tour taxis for this route. They're three times the price.
Choosing between Zicatela and Carrizalillo in Puerto Escondido.
Zicatela is a long stretch of dark sand with brutal surf. The beach break here is not for swimming unless you know exactly what you're doing. But the vibe is excellent: good restaurants on Avenida del Morro, yoga studios, and a laid-back international crowd that's been coming since the 1980s. Hotel Azul Cielo sits right on this strip.
Carrizalillo is 2 km south and feels completely different. It's a small sheltered cove, calm enough for kids and non-swimmers, and the 165-step descent keeps the crowds manageable. Villas Carrizalillo is the top pick here at $165-220/night. If you only have 2 nights and you're not a surfer, Carrizalillo is the better call.
Getting the most out of Oaxaca's food scene from your hotel base.
Oaxaca is one of the best food cities in Mexico. That's not hype. Mole negro, tlayudas, chapulines, and the best cheese market in the country at Mercado 20 de Noviembre on Calle Aldama. Stay in Centro Histórico and you're 5 minutes from all of it on foot.
For mezcal, Calle Murguía between Calle 5 de Mayo and Calle Tinoco y Palacios has half a dozen excellent mezcalerías within 2 blocks. In Nochiztle and Cinco Gentiles are worth a stop. Don't do mezcal shots. Sip it slowly, ask the bartender what they're pouring, and budget around $4-8 per glass for good artisanal stuff.
Oaxaca's best neighborhoods
Start in Oaxaca City if this is your first trip. The Centro Histórico and Jalatlaco put you within walking distance of the Zócalo, the Mercado Benito Juárez, and the best mezcal bars on Calle Murguía. The coast is a different trip entirely, and you'll need to choose it deliberately.
Oaxaca City 5 vetted hotels The cultural heart of the state. Stay here first.
The cultural heart of the state. Stay here first.
Oaxaca City is where most first-time visitors should base themselves. Centro Histórico and Jalatlaco are the two neighborhoods that matter most. They're walkable, well-connected, and packed with restaurants, markets, and colonial architecture within a few blocks of each other.
The Zócalo is the city's main plaza and a natural orientation point. From there, Templo de Santo Domingo is 8 minutes north on Calle Macedonio Alcalá. Monte Albán is a $4-5 taxi or colectivo ride, about 9 km west. You genuinely don't need a car if you're based in Centro.
Prices here range from budget guesthouses in Jalatlaco at $45-75/night all the way to Quinta Real Oaxaca at $195-240/night in a converted 16th-century convent on Calle 5 de Mayo. That's a big range. Pick your tier and don't compromise on neighborhood.
Puerto Escondido 2 vetted hotels Raw, surf-battered, and genuinely exciting.
Raw, surf-battered, and genuinely exciting.
Puerto Escondido splits into distinct zones and the difference matters when you book. Zicatela is the surf scene: powerful waves, an international backpacker and yoga crowd, and a strong restaurant strip on Avenida del Morro. Carrizalillo is the calmer, more sheltered option 2 km south, down 165 steps to a protected cove.
Getting here from Oaxaca City takes 25 minutes by air or 6-7 hours on the Sierra Sur mountain road. Most people fly. Aerotucán and Vuela both run the route. Oaxaca International Airport (OAX) has daily departures. Fly.
Hotels here sit in the $105-220/night range for the good ones. The cheap guesthouses on and around Avenida Pérez Gasga on the tourist strip are fine for a night but noisy and not particularly good value. Spend a bit more and stay on or near the beach itself.
Huatulco 2 vetted hotels Mexico's most underrated resort coast.
Mexico's most underrated resort coast.
Huatulco has 9 bays and about 35 km of coastline, most of it inside a federally protected zone. That protection is why it looks so clean: no shantytown development, no high-rise sprawl. La Crucecita is the residential hub with a central plaza, local restaurants, and grocery stores. Bahía de Chahué is where the upmarket resort hotels sit.
The Santa Cruz marina area looks good in photos but gets noisy at night and the restaurants are tourist-priced. Stay in La Crucecita or Bahía de Chahué instead. A taxi between any two bays runs $5-10 and takes 5-20 minutes depending on which bay you're going to.
This is one of the more expensive parts of Oaxaca state. Budget $130-185/night for mid-range, $320-480/night for a proper resort experience at Encanto. If that top end feels steep, Puerto Escondido gives you a coastal fix for significantly less.
Valle de Oaxaca 1 vetted hotel Mezcal country and Zapotec villages, 30 minutes from the city.
Mezcal country and Zapotec villages, 30 minutes from the city.
The Valle de Oaxaca is the agricultural plain that surrounds Oaxaca City: flat, golden, studded with agave fields and ancient ruins. Tlacolula, 30 km east of the city on Highway 190, hosts one of the largest indigenous markets in Mexico every Sunday. Mitla, 5 km further, has some of the best-preserved Zapotec stonework anywhere.
Staying here is a minority move, but a good one if you've seen the city before. Imala Hotel Boutique in Tlacolula is the standout: $260-340/night, boutique quality, and you're waking up in the valley instead of commuting to it. The Sunday market starts early. Being on-site the night before makes a real difference.
Colectivos from Oaxaca City's second-class terminal run to Tlacolula for 25-35 pesos and take about 45 minutes. Taxis from the city are $15-20. The valley sits at 1,500 m, so evenings cool down fast even in summer. Pack a layer.
Best Areas by Vibe
Tell us how you travel and we'll point you to the right part of Oaxaca.
Romantic
Santo Tomás Xochimilco in Oaxaca City is the pick for couples who want intimacy without the Centro Histórico crowds. Hotel Boutique Casa Oaxaca sits here, just 12 minutes from the Zócalo but quiet enough to feel like your own private Oaxaca.
Culture
Centro Histórico is the obvious call: Templo de Santo Domingo, Museo de las Culturas, Mercado Benito Juárez, and the Ethnobotanical Garden all within a 15-minute walk. Parador San Agustín on Murguía puts you dead-center in it.
Family
La Crucecita in Huatulco is calm, affordable, and genuinely set up for families, with a walkable plaza and calmer bay waters than Puerto Escondido. Hotel Santa Rosa sits 3 minutes from the main square and won't drain your wallet.
Budget
Jalatlaco in Oaxaca City is the best-value neighborhood in the state: colonial charm, zero tourist-trap pricing, and Casa Arnel at $45-75/night. You're 10 minutes walk from Santo Domingo and paying less than anywhere else on this list.
Beach
Playa Carrizalillo in Puerto Escondido is a protected cove with calm turquoise water, 165 steps below the road and worth every single one. Villas Carrizalillo is right there at $165-220/night.
Foodie
Centro Histórico is the undisputed choice: Mercado 20 de Noviembre on Calle Aldama for tlayudas and mole negro, Calle Murguía for mezcalerías, and some of Mexico's best restaurants within a 10-minute walk of the Zócalo.
Location Quality
Is the neighborhood walkable? Are restaurants, shops, and attractions within 10 minutes on foot? How does it feel after dark? We evaluate safety, public transport access, and whether the area has genuine local character or just tourist traps. A hotel in the wrong neighborhood ruins a trip. That's why location carries the most weight.
Value for Money
We compare what you pay against what you get. A €150 hotel with a great location, clean rooms, and helpful staff can outscore a €500 hotel with fancy amenities in a bad area. We factor in seasonal pricing, cancellation policies, and hidden costs like tourist tax and breakfast surcharges. The goal is finding the best ratio, not the lowest price.
Guest Experience
We analyze thousands of verified guest reviews across multiple platforms, looking for patterns rather than individual complaints. Consistent praise for cleanliness, staff, and room quality counts. We also assess the intangibles: does the hotel have character? Would you recommend it to a friend? A soul-less chain hotel with perfect facilities still loses to a well-run boutique with personality.
When to Visit Oaxaca
When to visit Oaxaca and what to pay.
Dry Season (Nov-Feb)
This is prime time. Oaxaca City temperatures run 10-24°C with clear skies and no rain. Día de Muertos on November 1-2 drives the biggest hotel price spike of the year, up 40-70% above normal in Centro Histórico and Jalatlaco. December and January are nearly as busy, especially around the Noche de Rábanos festival on December 23 in the Zócalo. Book at least 6-8 weeks ahead for any November or December stay.
Spring (Mar-May)
March through May is Oaxaca at its most manageable. Temperatures climb to 28-30°C by April and May, but rain hasn't started yet. Prices drop 20-30% from peak, and you'll actually get a table at restaurants on Calle Macedonio Alcalá without waiting. Semana Santa (Holy Week before Easter) is the one exception: the city fills up and prices spike for 5-7 days. Outside of that week, spring is excellent value.
Rainy Season (Jun-Sep)
Rain comes most afternoons from around 3 PM but usually clears by evening. Temperatures stay mild at 16-26°C in Oaxaca City. This is the cheapest window to visit and the city is actually beautiful after rain, with the green Sierra Juárez mountains visible on clear mornings. The coast is rougher: Puerto Escondido gets heavy swell and stronger currents on Zicatela from July through September. Not ideal for non-surfers on the beach.
October
October is arguably the smartest month to visit. The rains are winding down, temperatures settle at 14-24°C in the city, and you're ahead of the November Día de Muertos surge. Hotels in Centro Histórico and Jalatlaco sit at pre-peak prices, typically $75-170/night, but start rising from October 25 onward. Book the city for early October, stay through Día de Muertos if you can, and you've hit Oaxaca at its absolute best.
Booking Tips for Oaxaca
Insider tips for booking hotels in Oaxaca.
Book Día de Muertos accommodation by August
November 1-2 is the most in-demand hotel period in Oaxaca. Centro Histórico and Jalatlaco sell out completely, often by September. By October, you're looking at leftovers or hotels far from the Panteón General cemetery on Calle de los Muertos. Set a reminder in July. Seriously.
Fly to the coast. Don't drive.
The mountain road between Oaxaca City and Puerto Escondido is genuinely stunning, but it takes 6-7 hours of winding switchbacks. The Aerotucán or Vuela flight from OAX takes 25 minutes and costs $60-120 each way. For two people splitting a fare, it's not that much more expensive than a bus and infinitely better use of vacation time.
Avoid the bus terminal neighborhood for hotels
The area around the second-class bus terminal on Calzada Héroes de Chapultepec in Oaxaca City looks convenient on a map but is one of the worst places to base yourself. It's loud, sketchy after dark, and a $3-4 taxi ride from anything worth seeing. Add 5 minutes to your commute and stay in Jalatlaco or Centro instead.
Use colectivos for day trips in the valley
Colectivos from the second-class terminal on Calzada Héroes de Chapultepec cover most of the Valle de Oaxaca for 25-40 pesos per trip. Tlacolula for the Sunday market, Mitla for the ruins, and Santa María del Tule for the 2,000-year-old Tule Tree are all reachable this way. Private tour taxis charge $40-80 for the same routes. The colectivo is not scary. Just show up and say where you're going.
Altitude matters more than people expect
Oaxaca City sits at 1,550 m above sea level. If you're coming from a coastal city or sea-level home, give yourself 24 hours before doing anything strenuous. Monte Albán at 1,940 m can be rough in afternoon heat if you haven't adjusted. Drink water constantly. Skip the mezcal on your first night.
Carrizalillo vs. Zicatela: pick before you book
These two beaches in Puerto Escondido attract completely different travelers and are 2 km apart. Zicatela is the Mexican Pipeline: massive surf, dangerous for non-surfers, excellent bar scene. Carrizalillo is a sheltered cove, calm water, family-friendly, and quieter at night. Decide which you want before booking a hotel because switching mid-trip means finding new accommodation in peak season. Both neighborhoods have good options at $105-220/night.
Hotels in Oaxaca — FAQ
Everything you need to know before booking hotels in Oaxaca.
What's the best neighborhood to stay in Oaxaca City?
Jalatlaco and Centro Histórico are the two neighborhoods worth fighting over. Jalatlaco is quieter, more photogenic, and walking distance to the Templo de Santo Domingo in about 10 minutes. Centro Histórico puts you right on the action near the Zócalo and Mercado Benito Juárez, but expect street noise until midnight on weekends. Budget travelers do well in Jalatlaco. If you're paying $150+ a night, Centro Histórico gives you more for the money.
How much should I budget for a hotel in Oaxaca?
Budget guesthouses in Jalatlaco start around $45-75/night. Mid-range hotels in Centro Histórico run $100-175/night. Luxury boutique properties, especially around Santo Tomás Xochimilco and the Valle de Oaxaca, go $195-480/night. The coast follows similar tiers: Zicatela in Puerto Escondido sits at $105-165/night for the good spots, while Huatulco's Bahía de Chahué pushes $320-480/night at the top end.
When is the best time to visit Oaxaca?
October through February is the sweet spot. Temperatures in Oaxaca City stay at 18-24°C, the rainy season is done, and you avoid the summer crush. November is especially good: the Día de Muertos celebrations in the Panteón General cemetery are world-class, and hotel prices haven't yet hit their December peak. Book at least 6 weeks out for any stay overlapping November 1-2.
Is it safe to stay in Oaxaca City?
Centro Histórico, Jalatlaco, and Santo Tomás Xochimilco are all very walkable and safe for tourists. Stay aware after midnight on Calle Tinoco y Palacios and the streets immediately around the second-class bus terminal on Calzada Héroes de Chapultepec. Taxis at night are cheap, usually $2-4 for most Centro trips, and apps like inDrive work well here. Don't let online fear-mongering put you off. Millions of people visit without incident.
Do I need a car to get around Oaxaca?
Not in the city. Everything in Centro Histórico is within a 20-minute walk, and colectivo taxis on Calle Las Casas cover most neighborhoods for 10-15 pesos. You'll want a car or guided tour for day trips to Monte Albán, Hierve el Agua, or the Tlacolula market on Sundays. Car rentals from the airport on Carretera Internacional start around $35-50/day.
How do I get from Oaxaca City to Puerto Escondido?
The fastest option is a 25-minute flight from Oaxaca International Airport (OAX) on Aerotucán or Vuela, costing $60-120 each way. The mountain road by bus or car takes 6-7 hours but is genuinely stunning through the Sierra Sur. Most travelers heading to Zicatela or Carrizalillo fly. Book the flight at least 2 weeks ahead in December and August, when seats sell out.
Which hotels are best for a romantic trip to Oaxaca?
Hotel Boutique Casa Oaxaca in Santo Tomás Xochimilco and Encanto Resort and Spa in Huatulco's Bahía de Chahué are our two top romantic picks. Casa Oaxaca is the city choice: small, intimate, and 12 minutes walk from the Zócalo. Encanto is the splurge coastal option at $320-480/night, with a proper spa and direct bay access. Both earn their price tag.
Are there good family-friendly hotels in Oaxaca?
Hotel Santa Rosa in Huatulco's La Crucecita neighborhood is the standout family option at $130-185/night. La Crucecita is quieter than the marina area, with a central plaza the kids can run around and restaurants within a 5-minute walk. Oaxaca City is also excellent for families: the Mercado Benito Juárez and the Ethnobotanical Garden behind Santo Domingo are both easy half-days with children.
What's the best area to stay in Puerto Escondido?
Zicatela for surfers and nightlife, Carrizalillo for families and calm-water swimmers. These two beaches are only 2 km apart but feel like different towns. Zicatela is on the Mexican Pipeline, one of the most powerful surf breaks in the Americas. Carrizalillo is a sheltered cove you reach by walking down 165 steps from the road. Hotels on the Carrizalillo side run $165-220/night for the good ones.
Is Huatulco worth the extra cost compared to Puerto Escondido?
Depends entirely on what you want. Huatulco has 9 bays, cleaner water, more resort infrastructure, and calmer seas. Puerto Escondido is rawer, cheaper by about 30-40%, and has a better food and bar scene on Avenida del Morro. If you're honeymooning or want a spa, go Huatulco. If you're a solo traveler or surfer, Puerto Escondido wins every time.
What's the Valle de Oaxaca and should I stay there?
The Valle de Oaxaca is the broad agricultural valley surrounding Oaxaca City, home to Zapotec villages, mezcal distilleries, and the Sunday market in Tlacolula. Staying out here is unusual but genuinely special. Imala Hotel Boutique in Tlacolula sits right in the valley and charges $260-340/night. If you've done Oaxaca City before and want something different, a night or two in the valley is memorable.
Which areas of Oaxaca should I avoid when booking a hotel?
Avoid anything within 4 blocks of the second-class bus terminal on Calzada Héroes de Chapultepec in Oaxaca City. Noisy, gritty, and far from the sights. In Puerto Escondido, skip the hotels on Avenida Pérez Gasga right on the tourist strip unless you enjoy being sold things constantly. In Huatulco, hotels around the Santa Cruz marina look good in photos but the area is loud in the evenings and overpriced for what you get.